Select Region
Helping Parents Make Better Decisions
100+ Things to Do This Summer - Read the Guide Today!

New York Toy Stores Share Their Top Toy Picks for the Holidays

New York Toy Stores Share Their Top Toy Picks for the Holidays

With so many toys on the market, it can be hard to choose something unique that your kids will like, and not toss aside the next day. That’s why we’re leaving it to the experts. We’ve contacted some wonderful toy stores in the NY area to find out which toys are their favorites this season. 

1581 Route 202, Pomona

Toyriffic2 in Rockland County is all about Zeebeez. These topsy-turvy rubber pop toys flip inside out and fly up to six feet high. Catch them on the way down. They come in a variety of designs and colors making them fun to collect. The best part? They’re just $5 each. Yaakov Miller, owner of Toyriffic2, told us, “Every parent, after trying out the Zeebeez, automatically says [it’s] cool... and then I watch them try to catch [it in] the air.”

Learning Express UES
1029 Third Ave.

PlushCraft is the gift of choice from Learning Express. PlushCraft is a fun, no-mess craft. Kids match colored fabric to numbers and can create pillows, purses, and more without sewing. Marketing Manager for Learning Express Toys, Becki Harrington-Davis added, “The 3D Koala and Reindeer Ornament PlushCraft are exclusive to Learning Express Toys!” Prices range from $7.99-$16.99.

RELATED: Check Out These Great Stores and Party Place Near You

8722 Third Ave., Fort Hamilton/Bay Ridge

Brooklyn’s Kaleidoscope recommends the Synth Kit by littleBits. It’s an easy-to-use synthesizer that let’s your budding musician rock out. It connects to speakers, computers, and headphones and with any instrument that has a jack for an amplifier. Price is $159.

Fantasma Toys
421 Seventh Ave., Herald Sq.

If your child is into magic, Manhattan’s Fantasma Toys recommends the Ultimate Legends of Magic Set. For about $85, you get over 250 tricks to learn, an instructional DVD, a table to perform tricks, and a bonus DVD of some of the greatest magicians in action. “Fantasma Magic has been proven to improve a child’s hand eye coordination, improve public speaking and build self-confidence,” Roger Dreyer, CEO of Fantasma Magic, said. Your child will love the expressions on family members’ faces!

Kidding Around
60 W. 15th St., Union Sq.

Kidding Around isn’t kidding around when it comes to great gifts. This shop loves Magna-Tiles this season. They are plastic, colorful shapes with magnets for building incredible structures. Magna-Tiles are a good way to encourage play, engineering and math. $120 for a set of 100.

Not Just Art
183 South St., Oyster Bay

Not Just Art picks Keva Planks. These planks are great for problem solving, design, and engineering challenges. Kids can create buildings, monuments, and geometric forms. They are also a tool for collaborative play. The Keva Maple 200 set goes for $89.95. Eva from the shop also notes, “We offer art, science and music classes for children and in our shop we sell art supplies/kits, instruments, science and building toys, puzzles, games and imaginative pre-school toys.”

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest updates on fun events and other family activities in you area.


Want more content like this?

More Articles:

Shop Local at These Independent Toy Stores Around NYC

Here's a list of toy stores in and near NYC where you can do your last-minute holiday shopping.

Latest News:

16 Asian American and Pacific Islander (AAPI) Children’s Books

Here are 16 children's books about Asian American and Pacific Islander culture that your family can read during AAPI Heritage Month which is May.

Family Activities:

Garden Creativi-Tea

The Voelker Orth Museum Aug. 03, 2021

Join the The Voelker Orth Museum in the garden to make Wearable Felt Flowers & Bugs! Ado...

Have a Laugh:

Best Memes of the Week for Parents

Here are the funniest parenting memes from Instagram, Facebook, and Reddit this week.
Melissa A. Kay

Author: Melissa A. Kay is a writer, editor, and content strategist with over 15 years of experience in the publishing field in the areas of family, beauty, health, employment, lifestyle, entertainment, and more. She lives in Manhattan with her loving husband and inspiring cat, and enjoys reading, fitness, cooking, music, and the amazing experiences New York has to offer. See More

Featured Listings:

Clover Prep Learning Center

Clover Prep Learning Center

Fresh Meadows, NY Clover Prep caters to multiple learning styles starting from age 2.5 to 9th grade. All classes hold a 1:5 or 1:8, teacher to student ratio. This rati...

Music Together® With Music and Me

Music Together® With Music and Me

For hundreds of thousands of families worldwide, (and thousands in Queens!), Music Together is children and their grownups sharing joyfully in singing...

Mandarin Discovery School

Mandarin Discovery School

Mandarin Discovery Preschool program is an immersive and creative program for children 3 to 5 years old. Children learn Mandarin with musical instrum...

Ohman School of Ballet

Ohman School of Ballet

Commack, NY Now in its 34th year, the Ohman School of Ballet was founded by Frank Ohman, former soloist of New York City Ballet and is one of the few remaining di...